Monetary policies – A divide and conquer Covid approach?
In the aftermath of the Global Financial Crisis (GFC), central banks worldwide were applauded for their innovative monetary policies. Yet despite reacting quickly to this year’s economic crisis, COVID 19 has deepened fractures that were already emerging between the world’s three major economic powers: the US, Europe and China. This has led to monetary and government policy in these regions going their own separate ways. These three journeys can be represented as the good, the bad and the potentially ugly. So, what has driven this divergence and should investors be concerned?
Coronavirus: the great divider
In the first quarter, initial policy responses to the widening pandemic were broadly similar. Countries were locked down to stem the spread of the virus, with unprecedented economic stimulus used to shield economies and protect employment. While impactful, the lockdowns failed to fully suppress the virus and a second wave of outbreaks is being met with disparate approaches.
The US has prioritised protecting the economy and didn’t re-impose any meaningful restrictions when coronavirus cases spiked for a second time in the summer. European nations seem more willing to impose heavier restrictions, with many localised lockdowns being put into place in an effort to slow the spread of the second wave. This more stringent action will hinder the region’s recovery from an already severe economic downturn.
Even though the virus originated in China, the first outbreak was highly localised and no substantial second wave has broken out. While the initial, draconian lockdown triggered a sharp downturn in growth (and a decline in GDP), recent economic data suggests the country has rebounded quickly and China is now one of the few countries moving on to a post-pandemic economic landscape.
The potentially ugly: US presidential election
The US economy has benefitted from massive fiscal and monetary support, offsetting at least some of the impact of the lockdown recession. The Federal Reserve (Fed) has provided additional trillions in liquidity and by adopting a more flexible inflation target has signalled it will no longer pre-emptively raise interest rates to counter perceived inflation risk or fiscal stimulus. This has reassured markets by reinforcing the message that US monetary policy will remain accommodative for a long time.
For its part, the US Congress approved and President Trump signed a USD 2 trillion stimulus package the provided crucial income to the millions of people who lost their jobs. Unfortunately, a subsequent package has been held up by political gridlock between the Republican-ruled Senate and the Democrat-ruled House of Representatives. Discussions have now been shelved until after the election in November, though more limited, targeted measures are still possible.
Moreover, the election is being fiercely fought. There are several possible outcomes to consider:
It is unclear whether there will be a clear winner of the presidency on 3 November. If the result is close, President Trump has indicated he may contest the outcome, a situation that could drag on through the end of the year. This scenario could be very negative for markets in the short-term, as happened in 2000 when the outcome of the election between George W Bush and Al Gore was unclear.
Irrespective of who actually wins the presidency, a key issue is whether Congress will remain divided. As seen in the failure to agree a second stimulus, a divided Congress often results in gridlock and little legislation. This was the situation during the latter six years of Obama’s administration as well as the last two years of Trump’s. This outcome, a continuation of the status quo, would likely to still be viewed positively by markets as the economy would be left to its own devices as it recovers from the recession.
Finally, Joe Biden winning the presidency and the Democrats gaining control over the Senate, could be the most positive outcome for markets. This outcome would likely see the passage of a substantial stimulus package, which would also drive Treasury yields higher through expectations for higher growth and inflation.
The bad: Fresh lockdowns will damage the European economy
The European approach to a second wave has been very different to the US. Firstly, another round of lockdowns could see the European economy decouple even further from the US economic trajectory. Secondly, the region’s fiscal support programmes have been extended into next year and have centred on the protection of jobs and industries.
While this approach is supportive over the short-term, it prevents industry and employment from transitioning to the new post-pandemic world. And the consequent accumulation of zombie companies could be very detrimental over the long term. Reallocating financial support and labour to growth areas – a concept known as creative destruction – was proven to help industry recover in the aftermath of the GFC and is vital in enabling the economy to adapt to the much-changed post-pandemic world. But will European policymakers be brave enough to take this step?
The European Central Bank’s (ECB) monetary firepower has also come into question. With interest rates already in negative territory at the start of the pandemic, the central bank’s unwillingness to implement further cuts in March alongside the Fed and the Bank of England suggests the ECB realises negative interests may been causing more harm than doing good.
Finally, the ECB and European Union’s hard-won stimulus programmes may have helped curb market volatility, but have had little success in reviving inflation. An appreciating euro is adding to deflationary pressures and it is questionable whether the central bank has any tools left to stoke inflation or whether the European Union is able to provide further fiscal support.
The good: China’s self-sufficiency
China continues to surprise. The fact that the pandemic accelerated deglobalisation trends gave rise to assumptions that the pandemic would be especially painful for China. But this has not been the case. In fact, China is leading the path to recovery.
China is actually well positioned to take advantage of deglobalisation. While lower international trade would have been harmful earlier in China’s development, its economy is now highly focused on services and tilted towards domestic demand. And a population close to 1.5 billion1 effectively serves as its own internal market – very similar to the US’s self-sufficiency.
With comparative low (central government) debt levels and a closed capital account, China has an advantage over many other nations in that it can afford to provide further stimulus should it be required. This is not the case for many emerging markets, which do not have the capacity for more debt-funded spending or monetary stimulus, while currency instability and trade dependency create further headwinds.
Consequences for investors
Having enjoyed broadly benign market conditions for over a decade, 2020 has been unsettling for investors. Yet, while the overall vision for the near future remains cloudy, this century has taught us that disruption of any kind can lead to exciting and often revolutionary opportunities. And 2020 has certainly been disruptive.
At BNP Paribas Asset management, we look at investment from all different angles. This is why we truly believe that instability produces opportunity. While we maintain a cautiously optimistic outlook for risk assets over the medium term, we are acutely aware that the post-pandemic investment landscape could look very different. The process of creative destruction will identify those industries which have thrived and those whose demise appears inescapable. It is our job to find the best investment prospects for our clients.
To find out more about the investment themes discussed here, please complete the form below.
SUBSCRIBE
Get insights straight to your inbox.
Information dedicated to professional investors
This website is launched and published by BNP Paribas Asset Management, as defined at the bottom of every page of the website (the “Company”) Opinions on this website are the judgement of the Company, at the time specified and may be subject to change without notice. The Company is not obliged to update or alter the information or opinions published on this website.
By accepting this disclaimer as set out below, you acknowledge its content as being the mutually agreed terms for your visit of and the use of this website. Whereas the term “website” includes all content and data provided and all sub- and micro-sites of this website. Further, as a user of this website, you acknowledge, that you are responsible for ensuring that the legislation applicable to you in your jurisdiction permits you to consult this website and you represent and warrant that you have the necessary means and skills to access this website and use it in the intended manner only. This disclaimer is subject to changes without prior notice. If any of the provisions of this disclaimer are judged to be illegal or unenforceable, the continuation in full force and effect of the remainder of them will not be prejudiced.
Certain sections and / or pages of this website contain separate and / or supplementary conditions, including separate disclaimers, which apply in addition to this disclaimer and any separate and / or supplementary conditions. In the event of discrepancy between this disclaimer and any separate and / or supplementary conditions, the separate and / or supplementary conditions relating to the sections or pages of this website will take precedence.
Site Contents
The information provided on this website is for general information purposes only. It is not intended to solicit the subscription of or the sale of any financial instruments, products or services. In no event shall the content of this website be deemed to be investment advice with respect to any financial instruments or investment services. In addition, the presentation of any information on financial instruments or investment services in itself does not allow the making of a contract and should not be construed as an offer or placement of any financial instruments, or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any financial or investment services to any persons in any jurisdiction.
The Company is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority as an investment firm. The Company does not offer or purport to offer any direct lending or credit facilities to UK borrowers in connection with the SME Advanced Solutions platform or otherwise. Any potential borrowers should note that non-consumer loans and similar credit facilities are not regulated investments under applicable UK law and that non-consumer lending is not a regulated activity in the UK.
The Company disclaims any liability for any decision made on the basis of any information contained on this website. Potential investors and other market participants are encouraged to consult their own investment or financial advisers in connection with the purchase of any financial instruments or investment services or the entry into any borrowing or similar arrangements.
Exclusion of Liability
The Company including its parent company, subsidiaries, associated entities, directors, employees, representatives or suppliers, does not accept any responsibility arising in any way for errors in omissions from the information on this website and does not accept any liability for any loss or damage as a result of any person relying on any information on this website including any information provided by any third parties or by any inability to access this website at any time, except in the event of intentional or serious blame on its part.
Sources
All externally sourced information has been obtained from providers believed to be reliable, but its accuracy, timeliness, suitability and completeness is not guaranteed. For further information on fund(s), please contact the Company.
Links
This website may also contain links to websites which are published by third parties and third party websites may also feature links to this website. The Company has not reviewed any third party websites which refer to this website or to which this website refers for accuracy, topicality and / or completeness. The Company declines any liability in this matter. The fact that a link has been created to a third party website or that permissions have been given to a third party website to contain a link to this website, in no way means that the Company approves or recommends neither any content nor any products or services offered on a third party website. If you visit a third party website by following a link on this website this will be at your own risk.
Intellectual Property Rights
The information and data featured on this website is protected by law. Copyright and other intellectual property rights on this website (including registered and unregistered trademarks, brands, texts, graphics, logos, icons, sound recordings, software, etc.) are owned and licensed by the Company. You may use and / or print off the data solely for the purpose of personal, non-commercial use. You may not in any form or by any means:
• adapt, reproduce, store, distribute, print, display, perform, publish or create derivative works from any part of this website; or
• commercialize any information, financial instruments or investment services obtained from any part of this website;
• use any registered or unregistered trademarks from this website;
without the express prior written consent of the Company.
Privacy Regulations
By visiting this website, information on the access (e.g. date, visited sites, duration, IP-address) can be registered. Such data will be used in accordance with Cookies Policy of the website and will not be passed on to third parties neither for commercial nor for non-commercial reasons. By accessing this website you hereby agree, that the Company and its affiliates may record and process any personal data that you submit and which relates to you for the following purposes: customer management, including new business prospects, management of the contractual relationship, the prevention of irregularities, generating statistics and tests,. You also agree that this data may be passed on to all entities associated with the Company for the same purposes or to other persons in order to comply with any statutory obligation, or in the event of legal interests. You also agree with such notification, should the receiving person or entity be located outside the European Union, regardless of whether an adequate level of protection can be guaranteed for personal data in the country of receipt.
Within the Company and its affiliates, access to any of your personal data is restricted to those persons who need this data in order to fulfil their duties.
Electronic Mail Function
The option to use email to contact the Company is just one of the convenient features offered by the Company. You will be aware of the limitations regarding the reliability of sending and receiving emails, as well as the accuracy and security of email traffic, so you will understand that the Company cannot be held liable for any loss or damage arising as a consequence of queries which are not received, confirmed or processed, or as a result of the fact that your email may be intercepted by third parties. As a result you are expressly advised not to send any sensitive information via email, because it may not be secure. However, if you do so, it will be at your own risk.
Applicable legislation and jurisdiction in law
Your access to, visit to and / or use of this website and this disclaimer are governed by and will be interpreted in accordance with France legislation. The courts of France shall have sole jurisdiction regarding any dispute in this regard, notwithstanding the fact that the Company may choose another court that has jurisdiction regarding a similar dispute in accordance with an applicable item of legislation.